Thursday, October 19, 2017

There are no good teachers, only good learners.


We’ve all had bad teachers.  They were boring, mean, too strict, too lenient, smelly, slovenly, disorganized, inflexible, regimented, loose, uptight, humorless, silly, snobbish, condescending, groovy, juvenile, lecherous, creepy, insulting, rude, outrageous, opinionated, subjective, unfair, and incompetent.  They played favorites and we weren’t among them. 

Some of my best friends are teachers.  Throughout my career, there have been but a handful of teachers whom I haven’t gotten along with.  Teachers tend to be good people, civic-minded, caring, compassionate, empathetic, open-minded, quick-witted, intelligent.  The bad teachers described above have, for me, entered infrequently into classrooms I have known – either as a student or a teacher.  It doesn’t follow, however, that these good folk are good teachers.     

Caleb Gattegno, inventor of “The Silent Way,” an approach to language teaching that dramatically reduces the language a teacher may use and places the responsibility for language acquisition on the student, i.e, the one learning the language, once said at a workshop I attended, “There are no good teachers, though I might give myself the compliment on my death bed.”  This didn’t go over terribly well in the room, which was full of language teachers, many of them young like me and sure we had the answers to language teaching’s questions.   

One of the possible interpretations of Gattegno’s comment: The only good teacher is a dead teacher.  That’s a tad strong, I think (and hope), but I do believe the point Gattegno makes is valid: teachers talk too much.  How often I have observed colleagues whose lesson plan was executed to perfection, and took all the air out of the room.   Invariably, a question generated by a teacher ends up answered by the teacher, even if the teacher somehow manipulates a student to actually voice her (the teacher’s) answer.  The only questions allowed in a language class ought to be ones the students ask.  Then they’ll be more likely to come up with the answer.

No comments:

Post a Comment