Tuesday, January 30, 2018

Paying Attention in Class


Students pay attention in class, just not to the teacher (or to each other).

A number of years ago I saw a cartoon depicting a dog owner and his pet.  The owner was giving commands to his dog, such as: “Sit, Fido…Lie down, Fido…Shake my hand, Fido…Play dead, Fido…” and so on.  In the bubble over Fido’s head was written the following: “Blah blah blah, Fido…blah blah blah, Fido…blah blah blah Fido…”  In other words, there was little connection between what the person was saying and what the dog was hearing.  I’ve often thought this was an accurate description of the discourse of your typical high school classroom.  Examples of students’ inattentiveness to their teacher are legion: what teacher hasn’t complained about the student who asked what the homework was seconds after the teacher had just explained what the homework was.  Not mentioned as often is the inattentiveness teachers have to their students.  The same teacher frustrated by having to repeat herself umpteen times per class has no idea where her students’ attention lies.  This was true even before the advent of personal digital devices such as the smartphone; indeed, as much as I can’t stand the smart phone in the classroom, it is only making clearer the disconnect between teacher and student.  There has been a “smartphone” of sorts in students minds ever since the one-room schoolhouse. 

The truth is, it’s damn hard to pay attention to anything, especially for the lengths of time we ask teenagers attending high school to do it.  Of course, individuals vary in their ability to focus; it’s also not clear that intense sustained focus is always a desirable trait, but that’s a discussion for another day.  The point I’m trying to make is that it’s unrealistic for teachers to expect students to pay attention to them in any kind of sustained manner; on the contrary, it’s a small miracle that many students do remember the assignment and can follow instructions after hearing and/or seeing them just once. 

In any case, digital technology enables students to do just fine in a class without ever having to pay the teacher any attention at all.  High School courses today are buttressed, complemented, enhanced, even in some cases replaced by web sites and iPad apps and smartphone gadgetry, all of which let students upload and download and record and review and interact and recall and explore the content of their classes on line and on their own time.  While we aren’t quite to the point of the teacher’s being superfluous to the learning of her subject on the part of her students, we’re getting there fast. 

But returning to the subject of this post: paying attention.  It might be that paying attention is a skill all its own, and ought to be learned by youngsters (not to mention adults, though it may be too late for them).   Educators need to decide if a) paying attention is a discrete skill – like reading and writing – important for an individual to master and thus worth giving a place in the curriculum, and b) if it is, how exactly should teachers help students learn to pay attention?  My answer is, paying attention is a skill, and an endangered one at that, given all the digital distractions of the modern world.  It’s increasingly important in part because it is increasingly rare: when was the last time you felt you had the complete attention of anyone, even yourself?  Short of paying a therapist to listen to you for an hour, it’s really hard to find someone with the time, inclination, and ability to attend to you.  But somehow we expect teenagers, who have, to say the least, a few other things on their mind, to listen intently to teachers explaining the causes of the civil war, or the solution of a calculus problem, or how to form the present perfect in Spanish, for 75 minutes at a pop!  Blah blah blah…blah blah blah…blah blah blah.