Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Course requirements (aka “distribution requirements”) should be canned.


I am a product of a liberal arts education.  The renaissance man is my ideal.  For most of my life I have thought that an educated person ought to be “rounded,” meaning he ought to know a little bit about a lot of subjects, from the humanities to the math and sciences to the arts.  He should attend to his physical health and fitness, vote, and be able to hold a conversation with the shopkeeper and the scholar, the plumber and the professor.  He’s Dylan’s “Mr. Jones,” without the hypocrisy and narcissism.  He’s a hedgehog, wandering here and there, not a mole, burrowing into his own hole day after day.

I have changed, especially regarding the idea of distribution requirements, which is the practical application in high school (and college) of the liberal arts philosophy.  Maybe I’m just more jaded, though I’d prefer the term honest, but I think it’s absurd to inflict literature classes on fledgling engineers and physicists and geneticists et al, unless of course they are interested in literature.  Likewise, why should a poet take pre-calculus?  (Again, of course, unless she wants to.)  Should anyone be forced to take French or Spanish?  The truth is, students who hate a subject likely have no aptitude for that subject and hence will not learn that subject. 

Every year I ask my international students why they have decided to study in America.  The most common response is they have more freedom to choose what they want to study; also, they get to play sports.  They can’t stand the 13 classes they must take in their countries, the ridiculous tests they must pass in order to move on to the next level of school, the utter lack of creativity and activity in their ordinary school lives.  I think many American students go to school so they can play football or basketball, or act in plays, or play in the jazz band, or dance.  And every student goes to school primarily to see other students, aka their friends, who are entirely absent from distribution requirements.