Perhaps every teacher has at some point been given the
following advice (or something like it) by a mentor or administrator: “Don’t
smile until Thanksgiving.” As any
experienced teacher can tell you, it’s a lot easier going from too strict to
more lenient than the other way around.
Another way of saying the same thing is, don’t try to be friends with
your students. For young teachers
especially, this can be a difficult task.
I was young once, and for much of my career it was important to me that
my students liked me; in some cases, I wanted them to like me very much, like a
friend you might say. What a colossal
mistake! Teachers, repeat after me: I
will never try to make friends with a student.
Again: I will never try to make friends with a student. This quixotic quest – because that’s exactly
what it is – can only lead to feelings of betrayal, jealousy, anger, and hurt;
it will end up hurting you and confusing your student, and seriously compromise
whatever pretensions you have toward objectivity in your assessment of the
student’s work. To summarize at least
some of the reasons making friends with a student is a bad idea:
#1 reason: You’re her teacher. A teacher can help and coach and train and
inform and even console a student, among other things that a friend does,
too. But here are some things a teacher
must do to a student that a friend never does to a friend: give homework and quizzes and papers, mark
absent from class, grade a test or a composition, confiscate a cell phone,
assign a seat, permit a visit to the bathroom, and contact her parents when her
misbehavior warrants.
#2 reason: She’s your student. I don’t care how groovy a teacher you are,
how many times you bring zucchini bread or apples to class, how cute a nickname
you have your students call you, you are still in a position of authority in
the classroom, and to cede that authority in the interest of creating a warm
atmosphere or some such nonsense is a serious dereliction of duty on the part
of the teacher. In fact, creating a
sensitive, caring, warm “space” for your students can have the exact opposite
effect; a “first-among-equals” attitude on the teacher’s part will provoke anxiety
in the typical student because she will feel insecure and uncertain when the
authority figure attempts to be a good friend.
Trust me, most students have no problem making friends. What they need from you is an authority
figure that they can respect and oppose.
It’ll make them feel safe.
#3 reason: You’re an adult, and she’s a child. I remember my teenage years imperfectly, but
I recall quite clearly a father of a friend in those years who insisted on
hanging around with his kid and his kid’s friends at parties in said kid’s
basement. While the man was nice enough,
I suppose, (though he did have a nasty habit of semi-ejecting his false front
teeth), it felt wrong that he was there at all, drinking beer with us, laughing
loudly, telling stories, and I’m sure I wasn’t alone in feeling this way. “When’s he going to leave?” I kept thinking
as the clock hit 10, then 11, then midnight.
“Why isn’t he with his wife (who had the good sense not to hang out with
her child and her friends)? Doesn’t he
have friends of his own?” Generally
speaking, parents should be seen and heard as infrequently as possible when
their children are teenagers and with other teenagers. The parent who believes he can be “friends”
with his kids’ friends is only deluding and embarrassing himself, not to
mention his children.
The same can be said about teachers and students, only more
so. It would be downright creepy for a
teacher to attend a party given by one of his students (unless, of course, it
was the students’ parents giving the party, a graduation party, say). Teachers drift into treacherous waters once
they board the pleasure cruise with their students. But he doesn’t have to go so far as attending
a social gathering to send the wrong signals to a student; any “crossing-of-the-line”
between teacher (i.e., authority figure) and friend ought to be a no-no. If the teacher doesn’t know where that line
is, either he shouldn’t be a teacher in the first place, or he ought to find
somebody who can point out the line to him, pronto. I’ve become more conservative on this score
the longer I’ve taught, so I guess my “line” might resemble a wall at this
point. So be it. I simply can’t do an effective job if I worry
about my popularity in the classroom.
So, for me, not crossing the line means having students call me Mr. Griffin. It means students don’t
get my phone number. It means they
aren’t facebook “friends” with me. It
means my interactions with them happen on school grounds or field trips. In general, it means I maintain an arms
length distance from them, a level of formality that tells them, while I may be
friendly with them, I am never their friend.
