Thursday, September 28, 2017

We don’t know what we are doing.



We were discussing teaching writing at a department meeting, and a respected older teacher said, “We don’t know what we are doing.”  The comment struck me as odd; the school, after all, had developed an impressive writing curriculum including brainstorming, pre-writing, graphic organizers, outlining, multiple drafts, individual conferences, and every student-centered, writing-process technique known to academia.  And here was an esteemed member of the faculty questioning it all!

The longer I’m in this business, the less I know what I’m doing.  I’m pretty sure students learn something in my class, but I’m not at all sure my teaching has anything to do with it.  The course description I trot out at the start of every year describes a sort of platonic ideal I have for the class and bears in the end very little resemblance to what the class actually is, especially from the student’s perspective.  The homework I assign, the quizzes I give, the compositions, presentations, projects, discussions, role plays, pair work, language games, iPad apps, the whole kitchen sink of approach and methodology and technique and management, all of it may ultimately have little to no impact on my students’ actual acquisition of English.   I am skeptical that anything I do in fact teaches English to speakers of other languages.  On the contrary, it’s more likely that a few things I do actually hinders my students’ acquisition of English (giving grades, for instance).  Thoreau said, “That government is best which governs least.”  I can’t help but wonder if that teacher is best who teaches least.

No comments:

Post a Comment