Wednesday, November 29, 2017

3. The primary project of school is social, not academic or intellectual.



I remember almost nothing of what I learned in school.  When I think of school, I think of the people I met there: friends, mostly, but also classmates, teachers, coaches, administrators, cafeteria workers, and janitors who made an impression on me.  I remember the kid who ate a worm at baseball practice on a dare, and Rissa Russell, who fainted when a big fish swallowed a little fish whole and then regurgitated its skeleton in the fish tank in Mrs. Margolin’s science class.  I remember sticking tuna melts to the underside of cafeteria tables with my fellow miscreants in 9th grade.  I remember slow-dancing with a girl at a dance in 10th grade, and pretending not to care when the same girl slow-danced with somebody else.  I remember away games and bus trips and buckets of quartered oranges to stick in your mouth at halftime.  I remember the smoking lounge and not liking cigarettes but hanging out there anyway.   I remember Coach Devaney asking me if I wanted to be a “freak” or a “jock” in 10th grade, the clear implication being that how I answered this question would have life-long ramifications.  (It did.)

But photosynthesis? The quadratic equation?  The causes of the French Revolution?  The periodic table?  The term paper I wrote on Romantic Poetry?  Chaucer?   Any one of the lessons of the aforementioned Mrs. Margolin?   Whatever I know of any of these things has nothing to do with high school, and everything to do with the reading I have done – by choice – since.  Ah, you say, but you were exposed to all those subjects in high school; the reason you know a thing or two about the French Revolution today is thanks to Modern European History’s inspiring you to go out and read about it.  I have said as much myself in my capacity as both teacher and parent.  Why read The Great Gatsby?  Because it is the great American novel, of course, and will make you think about what it means to be American!    And, wait for it, it will lead you to other works by other famous writers, and you will be a richer (not materially, but intellectually, even spiritually) person for having read Fitzgerald.

Nah.  The argument won’t wash.  No one learns anything because they are forced to; they only learn things they want to.  Some students want to learn about the French Revolution, or math equations, or physics, or F. Scott Fitzgerald, or the cargo cults of New Guinea; others do not.  No matter what teachers and parents and college counselors tell them, students will learn what they want to learn.  Teachers and college counselors especially have no say in the matter; parents may exert some influence, if only by example.  But the influence of all these people in the child’s life pales by comparison to the child’s inner voice, and to the friends the child chooses to make.   

Thursday, October 19, 2017

There are no good teachers, only good learners.


We’ve all had bad teachers.  They were boring, mean, too strict, too lenient, smelly, slovenly, disorganized, inflexible, regimented, loose, uptight, humorless, silly, snobbish, condescending, groovy, juvenile, lecherous, creepy, insulting, rude, outrageous, opinionated, subjective, unfair, and incompetent.  They played favorites and we weren’t among them. 

Some of my best friends are teachers.  Throughout my career, there have been but a handful of teachers whom I haven’t gotten along with.  Teachers tend to be good people, civic-minded, caring, compassionate, empathetic, open-minded, quick-witted, intelligent.  The bad teachers described above have, for me, entered infrequently into classrooms I have known – either as a student or a teacher.  It doesn’t follow, however, that these good folk are good teachers.     

Caleb Gattegno, inventor of “The Silent Way,” an approach to language teaching that dramatically reduces the language a teacher may use and places the responsibility for language acquisition on the student, i.e, the one learning the language, once said at a workshop I attended, “There are no good teachers, though I might give myself the compliment on my death bed.”  This didn’t go over terribly well in the room, which was full of language teachers, many of them young like me and sure we had the answers to language teaching’s questions.   

One of the possible interpretations of Gattegno’s comment: The only good teacher is a dead teacher.  That’s a tad strong, I think (and hope), but I do believe the point Gattegno makes is valid: teachers talk too much.  How often I have observed colleagues whose lesson plan was executed to perfection, and took all the air out of the room.   Invariably, a question generated by a teacher ends up answered by the teacher, even if the teacher somehow manipulates a student to actually voice her (the teacher’s) answer.  The only questions allowed in a language class ought to be ones the students ask.  Then they’ll be more likely to come up with the answer.

Thursday, September 28, 2017

We don’t know what we are doing.



We were discussing teaching writing at a department meeting, and a respected older teacher said, “We don’t know what we are doing.”  The comment struck me as odd; the school, after all, had developed an impressive writing curriculum including brainstorming, pre-writing, graphic organizers, outlining, multiple drafts, individual conferences, and every student-centered, writing-process technique known to academia.  And here was an esteemed member of the faculty questioning it all!

The longer I’m in this business, the less I know what I’m doing.  I’m pretty sure students learn something in my class, but I’m not at all sure my teaching has anything to do with it.  The course description I trot out at the start of every year describes a sort of platonic ideal I have for the class and bears in the end very little resemblance to what the class actually is, especially from the student’s perspective.  The homework I assign, the quizzes I give, the compositions, presentations, projects, discussions, role plays, pair work, language games, iPad apps, the whole kitchen sink of approach and methodology and technique and management, all of it may ultimately have little to no impact on my students’ actual acquisition of English.   I am skeptical that anything I do in fact teaches English to speakers of other languages.  On the contrary, it’s more likely that a few things I do actually hinders my students’ acquisition of English (giving grades, for instance).  Thoreau said, “That government is best which governs least.”  I can’t help but wonder if that teacher is best who teaches least.